chordIdentifierPopJazz_0
Hi,
I'm using musescore on macOS 12.7, Arch.: arm64,
MuseScore Studio version (64-bit): 4.4.4-243461245
I installed the plugin, I open the window, but nothing appears.
What could it be?
BR
Daniel Sarkis
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
Hi,
I'm using musescore on macOS 12.7, Arch.: arm64,
MuseScore Studio version (64-bit): 4.4.4-243461245
I installed the plugin, I open the window, but nothing appears.
What could it be?
Many plugins stopped working at MuseScore 4.4, they'd need some porting effort.
In reply to Most plugins stopped working… by Jojo-Schmitz
Hi Jojo,
Any tips for doing this portability, or should we wait for new updates?
Thanks
In reply to Hi Jojo, Any tips for doing… by danksproducoe
See https://musescore.org/en/node/337468#Tips-for-adapting-plugins-for-4.x
In reply to Hi Jojo, Any tips for doing… by danksproducoe
In addition to the problems you can find on the page indicated by Jojo-Schmitz https://musescore.org/en/node/337468#Tips-for-adapting-plugins-for-4.x, in this plugin (and all its variants) the problem is in the RadioButtons. You need to replace the 'ExclusiveGroup' type with 'ButtonGroup'. Unlike another of my posts (where I had essentially eliminated the RadioButtons), in the file I attach everything works perfectly. The fix can be done in a few minutes...
In reply to In addition to the problems… by ILPEPITO
Could you add that to the document I linked to above?
In reply to Could you add that the the… by Jojo-Schmitz
I added the link...is that what you asked for? I thought it was implied...
In reply to I added the link...is that… by ILPEPITO
No, I meant adding the hint about the needed changes to that document
In reply to I added the link...is that… by ILPEPITO
(I see though why that missunderstanding, typo on my side, corrected now, I should not write anything before the 1st coffee)
In reply to (I see though why that… by Jojo-Schmitz
You can do it for sure and also without asking me anything from now on, for any interventions of mine. English is not my language and sometimes I don't know if I understood well...eh eh eh
In reply to You can do it for sure and… by ILPEPITO
Done, see point 12. in https://musescore.org/en/node/337468#Tips-for-adapting-plugins-for-4.x
In reply to In addition to the problems… by ILPEPITO
That change is incompatible to MuseScore versions prior to 4.4, isn't it?
In reply to That change is incompatible… by Jojo-Schmitz
To give a sure answer you should try... in reality the 'ButtonGroup' type works perfectly also in Musescore3, so the question should be limited to checking the imported libraries (and the 'quit' instruction). In principle it should also work in previous versions, but I don't have the way (and above all the time) to verify it.
In reply to To give a sure answer you… by ILPEPITO
Still talking about Musescore 4...
In reply to To give a sure answer you… by ILPEPITO
Doesn't work in 4.3: "Settings is not a type", so for different reasons it seems
In reply to To give a sure answer you… by ILPEPITO
But otherwise in 4.3: "ButtonGroup is not a type", so indeed incompatible as far as I can tell
In reply to But otherwise in 4.3: … by Jojo-Schmitz
'Settings' is also connected to RadioButtons. A library issue, I guess. All that remains is to recommend everyone to upgrade, hoping that with the next version not everything will change again...
In reply to 'Settings' is also connected… by ILPEPITO
No, settings is from Qt.labs.settings and doesn't exist anymore in the Qt version used by 4.4
In reply to No, settings is from Qt.labs… by Jojo-Schmitz
Interesting, one wonders how it is possible that it works...
In reply to Interesting, one wonders how… by ILPEPITO
Settings was ported to the plugin module.
(see https://musescore.org/en/node/361412 )
In reply to Settings was ported to the… by graffesmusic
Ah, I see
In reply to No, settings is from Qt.labs… by Jojo-Schmitz
As you have no doubt seen, the 'Settings' type in the plugin in question contains property declarations that are connected to the management of RadioButtons. Deleting the library it refers to should have given me an error (the first one I saw was 'ExclusiveGroup is not a type'), but instead, it seems everything works. If I were interested in the plugin, I would rewrite the entire interface, but frankly I don't feel like it: the 'mystery' of how and why the plugin works (at least in 4.4) remains.
Great job adding it to your document, but I fear that each plugin is a case in itself...
In reply to But otherwise in 4.3: … by Jojo-Schmitz
Probably the whole interface of this plugin should be rewritten, I use Musescore 4 from version 4.2...something and I have never had problems with the 'ButtonGroup' type. Best wishes to those who want to do it.