Stave distance widens if there is a cross-arpeggio
P1 - High
S3 - Major
- Open attached score (produced in 2.3.2).
- Click on note.
- Move up or down.
Result: The distance between the staves widens.
Any change will continue to widen it (e.g. repeating step 3; remove arpeggio and undo).
Also reproducible in a 3.0 score.
Using MuseScore 3.0 Nightly b1c66ae - Mac 10.11.6.
|Stave distance widens if there is cross-arpeggio.mscz||3.25 KB|
I have a score with the wide distance between staves, but I don't have to move notes to see an issue - hence the title.
#271331: [EPIC] Positioning, symbols, notation related issues
I can confirm this is still happening in the latest nightly build. You also do not have to open an score made in an older version for this bug to happen.
Also, the arpeggio collides with the flat symbol on the bottom staff. Maybe another issue should be opened?
yes, separate issue please
Fixed in branch master, commit 7077d96adb
fix #275962 Stave distance widens if there is cross-arpeggio
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.
I'm reopening this because the issue isn't really fixed in 3.0.5, and while it's different in master, there are still issues.
First, in 3.0.5, everything seems OK at first, but then the staves widen again on the first full relayout (or save/reload). In master, this doesn't happen, but the arpeggio actually fails to participate in autoplace at all - even when note extended cross-staff, n arpeggio that goes below the staff will collide with dynamics etc.
I guess the intent of the original fix here was a bit a of hack where we pretend the arpeggio has 0 height when calculating the shape for the chord, segment, and/or skyline, but it's still getting calculated as the actual height in other places at least in 3.0.5, so the timing of this is off. And in master, it's preventing autoplace from working at all.
I'm not convinced any of this is worth trying to fix in the way the original fix was trying to. Instead, I propose we do one of two things:
1) Require the user to disable autoplace when extending an arpeggio cross-staff.
2) Ignore the user adjustment to the height in calculating the shape for the arpeggio. Thus autoplace would still work with respect to the unadjusted portion of the arpeggio.
Related to #288373: [EPIC] Arpeggio issues
Came up again at https://musescore.org/en/node/325685#comment-1100748.